如何评价“反川死硬派”的克鲁格曼的这篇文章 《美国，懦弱的恶霸》?
【https://cn.nytimes.com/opinion/20190307/trump-trade-war/?utm_source=top10-in-article&utm_medium=articlepage&utm_campaign=web】
当中他观点我罗列一下：
1.USMCA还不如NAFTA好
2.贸易战对美国声誉造成损害
3.同中国的对峙中突然退却，这表明我们其实是雷声大雨点小。如果美国为了现实利益而改变路线，那又是另一回事。
4.破坏国际体系，美国正在让世界变成一个更糟糕的地方，对自己和对其他所有人都是如此。事实上，后果马上就来了。
克鲁格曼的一些经济书写得不错的，但是他这篇观点客观吗？还是出于反川头子的立场啥都要骂一番呢？
当中他观点我罗列一下：
1.USMCA还不如NAFTA好
2.贸易战对美国声誉造成损害
3.同中国的对峙中突然退却，这表明我们其实是雷声大雨点小。如果美国为了现实利益而改变路线，那又是另一回事。
4.破坏国际体系，美国正在让世界变成一个更糟糕的地方，对自己和对其他所有人都是如此。事实上，后果马上就来了。
克鲁格曼的一些经济书写得不错的，但是他这篇观点客观吗？还是出于反川头子的立场啥都要骂一番呢？
在克鲁格曼这种自由主义知识分子眼里，世界上所有国家开放国界自由贸易就完事了，世界大同立刻降临，市场无形地手解决一切问题。什么美国霸权，极权政府，文化差异，通通不与考虑。而且他还不是全球化精英里黑到多少钱的，那些人是坏，他这种就是蠢，那种liberal教育洗傻的蠢。
ooukcqiu
新注册用户
He's right. Nazi America would not care about freedom and Hong Kong ,
just as
"support ZTE" , and "delay tariff for communist china's day Oct. 1",
because
slow coward failure America just wants the trade war as long as possible, as slow slow slow as possible. And even that taxing on 550 billions was also said by America long long ago, just as said "soon" and "very soon".
America super loves rapists and Islam*c serial artistic killers who are rich and thus a good ally, as all know, removed and banned many many times.
Rape is nothing and coward USA would let communist rapist free, which is often banned to speak in redd*t. https://www.reddit.com/r/ask/comments/9f7gla/rape_is_nothing_and_coward_usa_would_let/
US supplied bomb that killed 40 children on Yemen school bus , with smart missiles which are smart enough to recognize and kill easy-to-kill children to show US has balls when being fucked off by hard-to-kill Russians. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/aug/19/us-supplied-bomb-that-killed-40-children-school-bus-yemen
Slow coward failure America likes to make the war as long as possible, already said far far more earlier and banned. https://old.reddit.com/r/ask/comments/9zxf1r/is_america_slow_coward_failure_again_where_is/
https://www.reddit.com/r/Kentucky/comments/8oqhe2/china_government_has_legally_stolen_37523/
Is slow coward USA doing the same thing that USA just waits a few months until China yuan is down 10% to $, then dares to tax 10% on $505 billions, and thus gets 10%-10%=0% in real trade? After all, USA has loved China communists and their ZTE for decades. My English is so bad?
1, USA shouts that USA would put tariff on $500 billion goods made in China to change anti-freedom trade with China.
2, China devalues (downs) its currency yuan 10% to USA currency $.
3, then USA dares to really put tariff 10%, and gets nothing in real trade because 10%-10%=0%, which means that prices of goods made in China are decreased 10% by means of China government devaluing yuan 10%, and prices of goods made in China are increased 10% by meanings of USA government putting tariff 10% on all, and thus prices in trade not changed in total.
4, ZTE is always controlled by China communists, and sells anti-freedom system to Iran and Korea, and banned by USA and then supported by USA later.
Just the first sentence I said, if you cannot read more sentences. "Coward USA is too slow, which would make the war last long and thus make USA fail eventually."
Coward USA is too slow, which would make the war last long and make USA fail. China yuan is already down 4% to USA dollar. So the real tariff in trade would be 10%-4%*500/200=0% for the new 10% tariff on $200 billions of China goods.
Notice: $500 billions is the minimal of goods made in China exported to USA. So China yuan downing (or devaluation of China currency to America currency, now about 4% down) affects more than $500 billions goods exported to USA, but new tariffs expected only affects $200 billions goods exported to USA. So the result of the new tariffs on the whole trade of goods made in China but exported to America here is only 10%-4%*500/200=0%.
Maybe USA can keep torturing Children (news about immigrants) and infants (news about USA believing cow milk is much better than mother milk or breast milk for infants), and make China communists keep stealing $375 billions and millions of American jobs from USA every year, since all these would make America great again.
Is USA a coward failure only shouting 200 billion and shouting 500 billion with doing nothing real while China communists have been keeping beating USA?
The simplest example in life to see the unfair robbery nature of China communists...(rob money from Chinese,rob work from American)
If you transfer money from banks not in China (for example, D) to China bank,Zero fee. But if you transfer back,that's to say, if you transfer money from China bank to banks not in China (for example,D), very high fee. That's the fairness? So, we got to know why China bank would not like fair competition with other banks, and China communists did unfair competition very well. (By the way, there is a little fact : China top four communist banks are the four biggest and richest banks all over the world. )
China bank says: If you transfer money out of mainland,for example, if you transfer money to USA , the fee is 1‰， 50￥ at least for each.And there is also tele fee,150￥ each time. And there also may be other fees. So, if you are a Chinese and want to buy an American goods, you transfer 500￥ to your account outside China, and China bank just simply takes off more than 200￥ from you just because you want to buy an American goods. Moreover, if you take this American goods back to China, you may face high tax by China communists as well because American goods' prices are much higher in China than in America while many Chinese goods' prices are obviously lower in America than in China . So, we got to know why China goods would not like fair competition with America goods, and China communists did unfair competition very well. (By the way, there is a little fact: China communists legally steal $375 billions and millions of American jobs from USA in 2017 by anti-freedom trade.) And all above here lasts for decades!
Seen in "China government has legally stolen 375.23 billions from USA in a single year by anti-freedom trade" http://bbs.aboluowang.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1062885&extra=page%3D2
Edit:I take no order from anyone. For those super Nazis, Can you and the followers read English?
Or you just don't want true free trade without tariffs?
Come on, Nazis and racists and communists, just ignore the truth, attack me and remove.
If no reply or late reply or this removed, blame voat or redd&t or radd** or other net or the gov, not blame me, because its not my control, and because "User is globally banned" or “Your account has been permanently suspended from Reddit.” or "Your account has been suspended from Reddit" or "you can't reply one in 9 minutes" or "You have been banned from participating in r/***" or "Your account has been banned" or "You have reached your daily comment quota. Your current quota is 10 comment(s) per 24 hours." which could also be false for you did not make 10 comments a day but you still cannot reply. I just say the truth, and I don't care whether you care. And the truth existence does not depend on whether you care. Nazibanfreedom Nazibantruth 5468764534 Nazilikestoban yuyvhjvv
"Soon" , and "very soon". "support ZTE" , and "delay tariff for communist china's day Oct. 1",
and "Xi is my great friend"..............
No one cares ,dude, because Nazi America still does not care about Hong Kong because Hong Kong has been decided as a dog of communists China not freedom China in 1997, just as 1949 and 1971, and of course the earliest is 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act . And of course America is first, although freedom China sacrificed more than millions of soldiers to defeat the only enemy who attacked China mainland and America mainland, and after that had been sacrificed by America with America doing nothing.
just as
"support ZTE" , and "delay tariff for communist china's day Oct. 1",
because
slow coward failure America just wants the trade war as long as possible, as slow slow slow as possible. And even that taxing on 550 billions was also said by America long long ago, just as said "soon" and "very soon".
America super loves rapists and Islam*c serial artistic killers who are rich and thus a good ally, as all know, removed and banned many many times.
Rape is nothing and coward USA would let communist rapist free, which is often banned to speak in redd*t. https://www.reddit.com/r/ask/comments/9f7gla/rape_is_nothing_and_coward_usa_would_let/
US supplied bomb that killed 40 children on Yemen school bus , with smart missiles which are smart enough to recognize and kill easy-to-kill children to show US has balls when being fucked off by hard-to-kill Russians. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/aug/19/us-supplied-bomb-that-killed-40-children-school-bus-yemen
Slow coward failure America likes to make the war as long as possible, already said far far more earlier and banned. https://old.reddit.com/r/ask/comments/9zxf1r/is_america_slow_coward_failure_again_where_is/
https://www.reddit.com/r/Kentucky/comments/8oqhe2/china_government_has_legally_stolen_37523/
Is slow coward USA doing the same thing that USA just waits a few months until China yuan is down 10% to $, then dares to tax 10% on $505 billions, and thus gets 10%-10%=0% in real trade? After all, USA has loved China communists and their ZTE for decades. My English is so bad?
1, USA shouts that USA would put tariff on $500 billion goods made in China to change anti-freedom trade with China.
2, China devalues (downs) its currency yuan 10% to USA currency $.
3, then USA dares to really put tariff 10%, and gets nothing in real trade because 10%-10%=0%, which means that prices of goods made in China are decreased 10% by means of China government devaluing yuan 10%, and prices of goods made in China are increased 10% by meanings of USA government putting tariff 10% on all, and thus prices in trade not changed in total.
4, ZTE is always controlled by China communists, and sells anti-freedom system to Iran and Korea, and banned by USA and then supported by USA later.
Just the first sentence I said, if you cannot read more sentences. "Coward USA is too slow, which would make the war last long and thus make USA fail eventually."
Coward USA is too slow, which would make the war last long and make USA fail. China yuan is already down 4% to USA dollar. So the real tariff in trade would be 10%-4%*500/200=0% for the new 10% tariff on $200 billions of China goods.
Notice: $500 billions is the minimal of goods made in China exported to USA. So China yuan downing (or devaluation of China currency to America currency, now about 4% down) affects more than $500 billions goods exported to USA, but new tariffs expected only affects $200 billions goods exported to USA. So the result of the new tariffs on the whole trade of goods made in China but exported to America here is only 10%-4%*500/200=0%.
Maybe USA can keep torturing Children (news about immigrants) and infants (news about USA believing cow milk is much better than mother milk or breast milk for infants), and make China communists keep stealing $375 billions and millions of American jobs from USA every year, since all these would make America great again.
Is USA a coward failure only shouting 200 billion and shouting 500 billion with doing nothing real while China communists have been keeping beating USA?
The simplest example in life to see the unfair robbery nature of China communists...(rob money from Chinese,rob work from American)
If you transfer money from banks not in China (for example, D) to China bank,Zero fee. But if you transfer back,that's to say, if you transfer money from China bank to banks not in China (for example,D), very high fee. That's the fairness? So, we got to know why China bank would not like fair competition with other banks, and China communists did unfair competition very well. (By the way, there is a little fact : China top four communist banks are the four biggest and richest banks all over the world. )
China bank says: If you transfer money out of mainland,for example, if you transfer money to USA , the fee is 1‰， 50￥ at least for each.And there is also tele fee,150￥ each time. And there also may be other fees. So, if you are a Chinese and want to buy an American goods, you transfer 500￥ to your account outside China, and China bank just simply takes off more than 200￥ from you just because you want to buy an American goods. Moreover, if you take this American goods back to China, you may face high tax by China communists as well because American goods' prices are much higher in China than in America while many Chinese goods' prices are obviously lower in America than in China . So, we got to know why China goods would not like fair competition with America goods, and China communists did unfair competition very well. (By the way, there is a little fact: China communists legally steal $375 billions and millions of American jobs from USA in 2017 by anti-freedom trade.) And all above here lasts for decades!
Seen in "China government has legally stolen 375.23 billions from USA in a single year by anti-freedom trade" http://bbs.aboluowang.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1062885&extra=page%3D2
Edit:I take no order from anyone. For those super Nazis, Can you and the followers read English?
Or you just don't want true free trade without tariffs?
Come on, Nazis and racists and communists, just ignore the truth, attack me and remove.
If no reply or late reply or this removed, blame voat or redd&t or radd** or other net or the gov, not blame me, because its not my control, and because "User is globally banned" or “Your account has been permanently suspended from Reddit.” or "Your account has been suspended from Reddit" or "you can't reply one in 9 minutes" or "You have been banned from participating in r/***" or "Your account has been banned" or "You have reached your daily comment quota. Your current quota is 10 comment(s) per 24 hours." which could also be false for you did not make 10 comments a day but you still cannot reply. I just say the truth, and I don't care whether you care. And the truth existence does not depend on whether you care. Nazibanfreedom Nazibantruth 5468764534 Nazilikestoban yuyvhjvv
"Soon" , and "very soon". "support ZTE" , and "delay tariff for communist china's day Oct. 1",
and "Xi is my great friend"..............
No one cares ,dude, because Nazi America still does not care about Hong Kong because Hong Kong has been decided as a dog of communists China not freedom China in 1997, just as 1949 and 1971, and of course the earliest is 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act . And of course America is first, although freedom China sacrificed more than millions of soldiers to defeat the only enemy who attacked China mainland and America mainland, and after that had been sacrificed by America with America doing nothing.